|  
 Remote Renewable Energy Resources made Possible 
                              by International Electrical Interconnections 
 A Priority for All Continents
Power Generation Technology - 
                              1994 Authors
                             T. J. Hammons, IEEE Chairman International Practices 
                              for Energy Development and Power Generation, Glasgow 
                              Univ., Scotland, UK
 
 J. A. Falcon, President, American Society of 
                              Mechanical Engineers, New York, NY, USA
 
 P. Meisen, Executive Director, Global Energy 
                              Network Institute, San Diego, CA, USA. OverviewOver the past few decades, international electrical 
                            interconnections have become increasing widespread 
                            as technology has improved and the benefits of integrated 
                            systems are realized. System interconnection facilitate 
                            reduced requirements for spinning reserve, improved 
                            efficiency, load leveling between time zones and seasonal 
                            variations, less fossil fuel emissions and the harnessing 
                            of remote renewable energy sources.  
 Expanding power grids have proven to be both economically 
                            and environmentally desirable. The utilization of 
                            the time zone and seasonal diversity that may exist 
                            between adjacent power systems can postpone or eliminate 
                            the necessity for commissioning new generating plants. 
                            System interconnections have improved the efficiency 
                            of the generation mix, reliability with respect to 
                            outages, and power system stability, frequency and 
                            voltage. Yet approximately 80% of all generation in 
                            the world is based on non-renewable fuels, whose emissions 
                            harm the environment, creating greenhouse gases, acid 
                            rain and toxic waste. With numerous sites around the world that boast of 
                            energy sources like hydro, tidal, solar, wind and 
                            geothermal, it is reasonable to project the benefits 
                            for the future if these renewable energy resource 
                            sites were connected into existing grids. In addition, 
                            the interconnection of existing electrical systems 
                            across national borders provides the benefits of a 
                            greatly expanded interconnected network.  Long Distance Transmission Studies performed by CIGRE (International Conference 
                            on Large High Voltage Electric Systems) [1] 
                            indicates that long-distance transmission can be made 
                            reliable and economically successful for distances 
                            of up to about 6500 kilometers with HVDC (High Voltage 
                            Direct Current) and 4800 kilometers with HVAC (High 
                            Voltage Alternating Current). This would permit inter-regional 
                            and even intercontinental power delivery from remote 
                            sites where large renewable energy sources may be 
                            found. An inventory of some of the best renewable 
                            resources shows them to be located throughout much 
                            of the developing world -- Latin America, Africa and 
                            Asia, as well as the northern latitudes of Canada, 
                            Alaska and Russia. Just as power is presently being 
                            purchased and sold every day to even out demand and 
                            alleviate power shortages among neighboring systems, 
                            so exports of excess power from developing nations 
                            can provide less expensive electricity for the industrialized 
                            countries, and financial resources for third-world 
                            countries.  Billions of dollars could be saved by sharing this 
                            untapped potential, and to a large extent, much future 
                            demand could be satisfied by wheeling rather than 
                            by building new plants. Savings from wheeled power 
                            are well established, and are reflected in reduced 
                            customer costs for the buyer and reduced unit costs 
                            for the seller. Since many countries are still unwilling 
                            to rely on too large a percentage of imported power 
                            for national security reasons, imported power usually 
                            displaces only the most expensive peaking generation 
                            units. Today, political enemies of old are quickly 
                            becoming trading partners. Just two months after the 
                            Berlin Wall was torn down, East and West Germany initiated 
                            the process of grid interconnection. Reported within 
                            days of the Israeli/PLO peace accords was the proposal 
                            to link the Israeli and Arab networks for mutual economic 
                            benefit.  The imported power need only be cheaper than the 
                            buyer's marginal cost for peaking power to create 
                            an economic win-win situation.  Total dependence of energy supply on a neighboring 
                            nation is unrealistic, yet emergency and reserve margin 
                            sharing quickly turns into economy energy exchanges 
                            as trust builds between parties. In any case, power 
                            transmission per circuit is usually limited to the 
                            amount of power the receiving system can afford to 
                            lose so to not cause instability in their system. An additional challenge for utilities today with 
                            regard to power transmission are Electro-Magnetic 
                            Fields (EMFs). It has become almost impossible to 
                            site transmission in some areas due to this cancer 
                            scare among the general public. Millions of dollars 
                            are presently spent researching the issue, with credible 
                            people coming down on each side. Epidemiologists state 
                            a perceived increase in childhood leukemia from 1 
                            case in 10,000 to 2 cases in 10,000. Extensive studies 
                            on lineman and telephone workers have shown no increase 
                            in risk. The authors view the EMF issue as a debate 
                            of the privileged in the developed world. Having the 
                            highest standard of living in the world, much of it 
                            supported via electricity, we live to an average age 
                            of 70 - 80 years old. For people in the first world, 
                            an EMF policy of "prudent avoidance" is 
                            a sound one for the time being. In most developing 
                            countries, having limited electricity, their living 
                            standard is dismal and supports an average life expectancy 
                            of 50 - 60 years. Their desire is for more electricity 
                            to improve their quality of life, and EMF is not an 
                            issue. Improved Living StandardsFrom a sociological point of view, the world's environment 
                            is rapidly moving out of balance in respect of its 
                            ability to support an exploding population. Most projections 
                            have world population increasing from 5.3 billion 
                            in 1990 to about 8 billion in 2020 [2], 
                            with almost all the growth coming from the developing 
                            countries. Predictions vary to the year 2050, but 
                            most population experts project about 10 billion people 
                            by mid-century. While population control could relieve 
                            many of the environmental problems facing the world, 
                            it is unreasonable to expect governmental decrees 
                            to accomplish such a goal. Population control will 
                            occur through two factors. Firstly, people around 
                            the world must move towards a rational approach to 
                            family planning. Secondly, energy in sufficient quantities 
                            must be available for basic infrastructure needs such 
                            as development of clean water resources, sanitation 
                            facilities, and refrigeration of food and medicine. 
                            Projected world population growth is illustrated in 
                            Figure 1.  In third-world countries, large families are deemed 
                            necessary to ensure that some of the survivors will 
                            be around to help with the work of sustaining the 
                            family, and to take care of parents when they are 
                            old. These "insurance births" are required 
                            because infant mortality is high as a result of inadequate 
                            health care, non-potable water and malnutrition. Thus, 
                            not only are infants at risk, but children as a group. 
                            When food and health-care systems can be sustained, 
                            fewer children are necessary for each family to function 
                            as working and contributing members of the community, 
                            and birth rates fall along with infant mortality [3]. In all social systems of the developed world, energy 
                            in the form of electricity provides for the efficient 
                            utilization of resources to supply food, shelter, 
                            health care, sewage disposal, transportation, communication 
                            and education. Clearly, power via transmission lines 
                            is a primary requirement of modern society, yet people 
                            in developing nations are more concerned with survival 
                            than with environmental protection.  World Energy DemandThe 1992 World Energy Conference has provided a comprehensive 
                            long-term global and regional energy perspective to 
                            the year 2020 [4]. A doubling 
                            of energy demand is projected, again mostly from the 
                            exploding population growth and the subsequent energy 
                            needs of the developing world. Three global energy 
                            cases representing different assumptions in terms 
                            of economic development, energy efficiencies, and 
                            environmental impact have been considered.  
                             The Reference (REF) Case, in essence the same 
                              developed by the World Energy Conference for the 
                              Montreal (1989) Congress, which forecasts that future 
                              energy demand will rise from 8.7 Gigotonnes of oil 
                              equivalent (Gtoe) in 1990 to 13.3 Gtoe in 2020, 
                              the other two cases are variants included to illustrate 
                              sensitivities to changes in the basic assumptions.
 
 The Enhanced Economic Development (EED) Case, 
                              which assumes a somewhat higher economic growth 
                              in developing countries (4% GNP growth over 3%), 
                              and suggests that global energy demand will rise 
                              to 17.2 Gtoe. 
 
 The Ecologically Driven (ED) Case, which assumes 
                              the same economic growth as for the REF Case but 
                              with a sharper improvement in energy efficiency, 
                              shows that energy demand will rise to only 11.2 
                              Gtoe by the year 2020.  Global energy mix in the year 2020 for these three 
                            assumptions is depicted in Table 1 and in Figure 2. 
                            It is seen that the WEC estimates commercial fossil 
                            fuels will continue to dominate the energy mix to 
                            the year 2020, and are likely to continue to do so 
                            far into the next century. From a total fossil fuel 
                            ratio (that is, the ratio between commercial fossil 
                            fuel consumption and total fuel use) at 78% in 1990, 
                            it becomes 73% in the REF Case, 75% in the EED Case, 
                            and 63% in the ED Case in the year 2020. New renewable energy sources will be seen to play 
                            an increasing role in the energy mix as we move into 
                            the next century. They should increase by 2.5 to 7.5 
                            times current production, while hydro generation is 
                            expected to double by the year 2020. The contribution 
                            from nuclear power is also expected to double, but 
                            this will require resolution of some of the issues 
                            of public concern, such as technical safety in operation, 
                            management skills, effective international inspection, 
                            and safe long-term disposal of radioactive waste. 
                            Cost effective development and implementation of new 
                            renewable energy resources over the coming decades 
                            will be necessary to maximize the contribution they 
                            can make to the diversification of energy sources 
                            and the long term security of supply. Up until today, 
                            their lack of commercial viability limited large scale 
                            implementation of new renewables in the world energy 
                            system because of heavy weighting of initial capital 
                            cost. CO2 Emissions and EnvironmentThe Inter-Governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 
                            working for the 1992 Earth Summit projected a doubling 
                            of CO2 emissions over the period to 2020 [5]. 
                            Although the consequences of these emissions are still 
                            in dispute, it does appear that a prime solution to 
                            the global problem is to effect a transition by tapping 
                            many of the potential renewable resources and transmitting 
                            the energy electrically to areas of high demand by 
                            high voltage transmission. Industrial CO2 emissions 
                            predicted by the IPCC on Climate Change are illustrated 
                            in Figure 3. A 60% reduction in CO2 from 1990 levels 
                            is recommended to stabilize CO2 concentrations in 
                            the atmosphere in respect of climate change.  Many in the environmental community are promoting 
                            demand side management as one answer to our environmental 
                            problems. While demand side efficiency is important 
                            for advanced economies, this will not solve the energy 
                            needs of the growing economies in the developing world. 
                           Nuclear advocates rightfully state that fission produces 
                            no CO2 pollution, and is therefore an good solution 
                            to the greenhouse problem. Yet, nuclear power is politically 
                            impossible to build in many countries around the world, 
                            and except for Japan and France, has failed economically 
                            when compared to other generation options. Another 
                            Chernobyl-style accident could cause a political shift 
                            and curtail nuclear development even further. Engineers have the means and the mandate to generate 
                            benefits beyond system reliability and efficiency, 
                            which have been hallmarks of the profession. In 1971, 
                            The United Nations Natural Resources Committee proposed 
                            the interconnection of central Africa to Europe and 
                            Latin America to North America as a means of displacing 
                            polluting generation in the North with renewable energy 
                            resources from the South [6]. 
                            At that time the technology of long-distance high-voltage 
                            transmission was in its infancy. Today this technology 
                            is available and proven. Twenty years ago, architect and inventor Dr. R. Buckminster 
                            Fuller proposed interconnecting regional power systems 
                            into a single, continuous worldwide electric energy 
                            grid as the number one solution to solve many of the 
                            world's most pressing problems. While this vision 
                            is still years away, Fuller foresaw power grids as 
                            a means of improving the standard of living for the 
                            impoverished, preserving the environment and enhancing 
                            international trade and cooperation. Intercontinental TiesThe concept of intercontinental connections was addressed 
                            in detail at meetings of the IEEE/PES (Institute of 
                            Electrical and Electronic Engineers - Power Engineering 
                            Society) (January 1992, New York, NY [7], 
                            and February 1993, Columbus, OH [8]) 
                            where specialists from utilities, the United Nations, 
                            and the World Bank discussed the potential of tapping 
                            remote renewables using long-distance, high-voltage 
                            interconnections.  Panelists, who were engineers from the United States, 
                            Canada, Egypt, Brazil, India, Italy, the United Kingdom 
                            and Saudi Arabia, were experts in the field of system 
                            planning, design, construction and operation of high-voltage 
                            systems in all parts of the world. The consensus was 
                            that inter-regional interconnections were feasible 
                            and desirable today. It was stated that there had 
                            never been a known economic failure (save disruption 
                            through war), and every interconnection had proved 
                            to be of greater economic benefit than was the justification 
                            for its construction in the first place [7]. 
                           In many cases these regional links would be inter-continental 
                            ties. Several technically feasible concepts were presented 
                            - for example, a connection between the two American 
                            continents to capitalize on the great hydro resources 
                            of South America. Power sold to the North would bring 
                            economic benefits to Latin America. While cheaper 
                            electricity would aid the economies in North America, 
                            reimbursement to Latin America could be used for developmental 
                            needs as well as for debt repayment.  Additional ties under feasibility study include interties 
                            between Central Africa and Egypt, with connections 
                            to the Middle East countries [7,8], 
                            and from Iceland to the UK [9]. 
                            A major link between Africa and Europe has its basis 
                            in the vast hydro energy available from the Zaire 
                            River. The Grand Inga power station on the Zaire River 
                            represents a typical example of power supply that 
                            can be exported using international transmission lines. 
                            The characteristics of this potential development 
                            are:  
                            30,000MW of installed capacity 
 
240 billion KWh annual energy production
 
Less than $1,000 per KW installed cost
 
Low environmental impact. In 1984, Dr Luigi Paris, Energy and Transmission 
                            consultant of Rome, Italy and Nelson de Franco of 
                            the World Bank's Energy Infrastructure Department, 
                            have suggested Inga electricity could be delivered 
                            to Europe at a price competitive with fossil generation 
                            it would supplement or replace [1]. 
                            Recently, Yehia Abu-Alam of the Science, Technology, 
                            Energy, Environment, and Natural Resources Division 
                            of the United Nations further calculated that the 
                            energy cost of Inga hydropower to Europe would be 
                            25% cheaper than domestic European nuclear power, 
                            and half the cost of European coal generation [8]. 
                            See Table 2 and Figure 4.  Transnational connections from Zaire have several 
                            potential land corridors. Transmission lines could 
                            traverse African Countries in the western, central 
                            and eastern portions of that continent, terminating 
                            in Spain, Italy, Greece or Turkey. Because of the 
                            long distance, HVDC would be mandatory for transmission, 
                            requiring six to ten bipolar lines. These lines, traversing 
                            desert and sea, would require careful siting to minimize 
                            exposure to harsh environments where, for example, 
                            tower footings would be unstable in the sand, and 
                            where excessive depth of the Mediterranean Sea would 
                            limit installation of the cables. Selecting an operating 
                            voltage of +600 kV, tower line space could 
                            be minimized for the overhead portion and paper-insulated 
                            submarine cable could be used for the underwater installation. 
                           Underwater cabling is commonplace, with DC links 
                            between England and France, and across the Cook Strait 
                            in New Zealand for just two examples. The plan for 
                            a submarine cable between Spain and Morocco at the 
                            Strait of Gibraltar is being studied. The whole African 
                            system is based on proven technology and appears feasible 
                            with low risk. The proposed Zaire/Europe development 
                            is illustrated in Figure 5.  Possibilities of a submarine power link between Iceland 
                            and the UK have been investigated for several years 
                            [9]. The National Power Company 
                            of Iceland, Landsvirkjun, which could provide un-utilized 
                            surplus of potential hydro-power amounting to 25,000 
                            -30,000 GWh/year and geothermal power useful for electricity 
                            generation of at least 20,000 GWh/year, have recently 
                            stepped up its investigation of the link. Conclusions 
                            were released early 1993 in the form of a pre-feasibility 
                            study on the proposed development. The study was conducted 
                            with the assistance of Pirelli Cables (Italy and UK), 
                            Vattenfall Engineering (Sweden) and local consultants. Results affirm the technical viability of the link. 
                            Particulars of the proposed 2400 MW development, including 
                            its economic prospects, are summarized in Table 3. 
                           Pirelli's review includes technical particulars of 
                            a "state of the art" design as well as a 
                            "near future" design (3-5 years). The cost 
                            of power delivered by the link is based on an economic 
                            analysis of suitable generation from contemplated 
                            East Iceland hydro electric plants.  The Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) and 
                            Alaskan power system planners recently met to discuss 
                            an East/West intertie between Alaska and Siberia [10]. 
                            While this interconnection may be years away, enormous 
                            hydro and tidal potential exists in these northern 
                            latitudes. However, the load is thousands of kilometers 
                            away - in Asia and the United States. In this connection, 
                            a promising possibility would be to install an 8000 
                            kilometer HVDC line from the US/Canadian grid, across 
                            Alaska, the Bering Strait and Siberia and into the 
                            eastern Russian grid. It is only a short step from 
                            that scenario to one that includes an interconnection 
                            between Russia and its Asian neighbors: Japan, North 
                            and South Korea and China. See Figure 6. With long distance HVDC transmission, one of the 
                            world's premier tidal sites could be developed at 
                            Penzhinskaya in Russia's Okhotsk Sea. This power could 
                            be fed into this multi-terminal system to Asian markets, 
                            or used for hydrogen production and shipped to these 
                            same customers. Potential tidal power sites considered 
                            for development worldwide are summarized in Table 
                            4. See references [11,12] 
                            for Tidal Power Generation prospects. The six nation Gulf Cooperation Council (Kuwait, 
                            Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Qatar, United Arab Emirates, 
                            and Oman) have commissioned a HVAC and HVDC system 
                            along the Persian Gulf [13]. 
                            All states operate at 50Hz except Saudi-Arabia which 
                            operates at 60Hz. AC/DC/AC couplers link Saudi Arabia 
                            to neighboring systems.  Clearly, the most critical world region for future 
                            energy demand will be India, China and Southeast Asia. 
                            More than half the world's population lives in this 
                            region, and energy demand is projected to surpass 
                            that of the first world by the turn of the century 
                            [14]. The enormous hydro, 
                            solar, and tidal resources of the region offer great 
                            opportunity for long term sustainable development. 
                            In each of these cases, the state of the art in network 
                            integration transcends national boundaries. The hurdles 
                            to tapping these immense renewable reserves are political 
                            in nature, not technical.  East-West European InterconnectionsWith the end of the Cold War, the Commonwealth of 
                            Independent States and East European engineers are 
                            working to upgrade and strengthen the former Comecon 
                            Electricity Grid system [15,16]. 
                            Synchronous coupling of the power grids on either 
                            side of the former Iron Curtain makes economic sense 
                            as reported by a meeting sponsored by UNESCO and the 
                            International Union of Producers and Distributors 
                            of Electrical Energy (UNIPEDE). At a few points along 
                            the former Iron Curtain, AC/DC/AC interconnections 
                            with or without DC lines already interconnect the 
                            two systems asynchronously at first. The DC technique can be used in two ways: without 
                            or with DC lines. The first is the way it is done 
                            today, using back-to-back stations along the old border 
                            between East and West Europe. These stations would 
                            be strung along the border between the synchronized 
                            systems. The other approach is to build several DC 
                            lines, penetrating some distance into both synchronized 
                            systems to form so called "staples". The 
                            conversion stations are then at either end of the 
                            line and also, if necessary, at intermediate points 
                            forming a multi-terminal configuration.  An advantage of back-to-back converter stations is 
                            their total control over electric power flowing through 
                            the two electric systems they join, while in the event 
                            of serious incident, they prevent cascading collapse. 
                            Stapled systems using DC lines gives good control 
                            of power flow between the systems. DC lines are themselves 
                            cheaper than AC lines because their insulation voltage 
                            is reduced by a factor of root two. DC lines allow 
                            for simple separation in the event of faults at either 
                            end of the system. Since DC interconnections decouple 
                            the requirement of common frequency, no stability 
                            problems are anticipated.  In general, existing AC transmission lines are preferred 
                            for the interconnections, as this method allows a 
                            better coordination between systems on both sides 
                            of the border at optimized cost and in a far more 
                            flexible manner than DC systems would allow. International 
                            collaboration on this technical issue is essential 
                            if fully synchronized interconnections are to go ahead. 
                            Within an interconnected electricity system, frequency 
                            must be cooperatively managed and collectively stabilized 
                            among all members of the power pool. Synchronization may have to follow three stages. 
                            First would come the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Poland 
                            and Hungary; next, countries like Bulgaria, Romania, 
                            and Turkey. Finally, extensions would be possible 
                            into other countries. Additionally, system planners 
                            in Europe have designs to interconnect with North 
                            Africa via underwater cable to Gibraltar, Italy 
                            and through the Middle East. UNIPEDE reports that 
                            large transfers of energy across Europe will be possible 
                            in the long term.  Another opportunity lies with the regional concern 
                            over Chernobyl style nuclear plants in Eastern Europe 
                            [16]. Decommissioning of 
                            such plants is difficult at this time because the 
                            power is needed in Eastern Europe. Western Europe 
                            is investing heavily in safeguarding against further 
                            nuclear accidents. Imported power may be an alternative. 
                           Benefits and OpportunitiesQuality of life in the developed world is directly 
                            related to and a function of the electrical infrastructure. 
                            In a similar manner, the striving for improved living 
                            standards in the developing nations is a direct function 
                            of the supply of their electricity requirements. As an example, the social benefits of the Grand Inga 
                            project would be significant for developing countries 
                            in Africa, since the energy produced comes from a 
                            renewable source, and income from energy sales would 
                            provide needed revenue for governmental programs intended 
                            to alleviate poverty. The export of a renewable resource 
                            does not reduce the potential richness of the producing 
                            country, and therefore does not compromise its future 
                            development. The scheme provides impetus for continued 
                            development, and enhances the ability to repay existing 
                            debt.  An examination of just a few areas in the world where 
                            renewable energy sources exist provides some idea 
                            of the potential of the grand plan for intercontinental 
                            exchange of energy:  
                             Large untapped hydro sites can be found in Latin 
                              America, Canada, Alaska, Siberia, Southeast Asia, 
                              and Africa.
 
 Tidal sites are found in Argentina, Canada, Siberia, 
                              China, Australia, and India.
 
 Solar potential rings the earth in Mexico, the 
                              United States, Africa, the Middle East, Russia, 
                              India, China and Australia. 
 
 Geothermal potential exists around the Pacific 
                              Ocean's "ring of fire", in the rift valley 
                              of Africa, Australia and an Iceland. 
 
 Wind potential exists on all continents, with 
                              geography providing some ideal sites in mountains 
                              and along coastlines. The potential capacity of these resources is massive. 
                            To state but a few examples -- Asea Brown Boveri reports 
                            that the world presently uses 14% of the exploitable 
                            hydro, and that a doubling would reduce CO2 emission 
                            on the planet by one-third. [17] 
                            Variable speed wind turbines have reduced costs to 
                            about $.05/KWh, and the Union of Concerned Scientists 
                            projects that much of the U.S. Midwest States new 
                            capacity demand of 2005 can be wind generated with 
                            no loss of reliability or increase in cost. [18] 
                            The tidal power of the Kimberly region in northwest 
                            Australia has the potential of eight times the present 
                            energy demand of the entire continent [19]. 
                            Given the remote nature of this and other similar 
                            sites, in addition to electrical generation, hydrogen 
                            production would also be a logical development scheme 
                            for use in the transportation sector. This would again 
                            provide a fuel that is essentially combustion-clean, 
                            and extend the life of petroleum reserves on the planet. 
                           Today, over 400MW of solar thermal power provides 
                            utility-scale electricity to Southern California at 
                            competitive peak rates, $.08 - $.12/KWh. For the next 
                            century, Sanyo Electric of Japan has proposed a grid-connected, 
                            worldwide photovoltaic energy system, using solar 
                            cells with 10% conversion efficiency and an area of 
                            800km x 800km (about 4% of the world's deserts). Sanyo's 
                            Kuwano projects the scheme would generate the equivalent 
                            of the world's petroleum use in 2000 (1.4 x 10,000,000,000 
                            kiloliters per year -- 10 to power of 10). [20] 
                           Clearly, renewable resources are abundant, yet site 
                            specific, and often in remote locations across political 
                            boundaries. At present, the only renewable resource 
                            that adds a significant portion to the global generation 
                            mix is hydro. Less than 100MW per year of new capacity 
                            comes from the other renewables. The energy demands 
                            of 250,000 new people per day cannot be met at this 
                            rate. While many development experts emphasize small, 
                            localized generation as the priority to meet the immediate 
                            survival needs in rural developing countries, this 
                            micro generation cannot meet the demands of 100 million 
                            new people every year. A combination of both small 
                            and large scale development of renewable energy resources 
                            seems essential. Using the business-as-usual scenarios of the World 
                            Energy Conference portends a future of further environmental 
                            pollution. With the costs of variable speed wind turbines 
                            and solar thermal generation now becoming cost competitive 
                            with base-load coal and gas-fired peaking rates, vast 
                            renewable sites in remote locations can now be available 
                            to meet this exploding demand with less impact on 
                            the environment. As stated in the new volume, "Renewable 
                            Energy: Sources for Fuels and Electricity", most 
                            of the electricity produced from these sources would 
                            be fed into large electrical grids and marketed by 
                            electric utilities [21]. 
                           In contrast to the WEC scenarios, Johannsen, Kelly, 
                            et al propose that at least 60% of the world's generation 
                            could be met from renewable resources by 2025, and 
                            that higher levels could be realized if nations should 
                            desire greater CO2 reductions. Of importance is the 
                            conclusion that the renewable energy development indicated 
                            in their Renewables Intensive Global Energy Scenario 
                            represents a tiny fraction of the technical potential 
                            of renewable energy. See Figure 7. Of concern for all is China's coal-fired development, 
                            adding a new thermal power plant every month. Continuing 
                            down this path will negate the efforts of the rest 
                            of the world to reduce CO2 emissions to levels recommended 
                            by the IPCC for the Earth Summit. Yet China is geographically 
                            surrounded by renewable resource options: hydro in 
                            the Himalayas and the Lena, Yenisey and Ob Rivers 
                            of Siberia; the Tibetan plateau and Mongolian deserts 
                            offer tremendous solar radiation; and several tidal 
                            sites exist along the Yellow, East and South China 
                            Seas No one can deny Asia's desire for improved living 
                            standards, yet everyone on the planet is ultimately 
                            affected by their energy decisions in the next few 
                            years.  The large number of locations where development is 
                            possible shows the scope for world-wide cooperation 
                            in a technology that can serve as a common point of 
                            interest for all countries. As noted by Yuri Rudenko 
                            and Victor Yershevich of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 
                            the creation of a unified electrical power system 
                            would not be an end in itself [22]. 
                            Rather, it was their view that a unified system would 
                            be the natural result of systems that demonstrated 
                            benefits in terms of economics, ecology and national 
                            priorities.  Possibly the most encouraging endorsement for the 
                            linking of renewable resources is a result of the 
                            Earth Summit in June 1992 in Rio de Janeiro. Noel 
                            Brown, North American Director of the United Nations 
                            Environmental Program, stated that tapping of remote 
                            renewable resources is one of the most important projects 
                            to further the cause of environmental protection and 
                            sustainable development. Engineers have the responsibility of designing systems 
                            for the long term sustainability of our planet. We 
                            have seen the consequences of past errors, and that 
                            of short term thinking. The question of how we can 
                            provide sustainable development and environmental 
                            protection for the long term must be high on the list 
                            of critical issues of all nations.  
 Figure Captions (in order of appearance in paper) Figure 1. Projected 
                            Global Population  Table 1. Global Fuel Use, Past and Future Energy 
                            Mix (Gigatonnes of Oil Equivalent)  Figure 2. Alternative Energy Futures  Figure 3. Industrial CO2 Emissions  Table 2. Cumulative present worth of revenue requirements 
                            in 2002 and levelized cost per megawatthour Figure 4. Inga hydro generation project: Hydro 
                            vs. European nuclear or coal Figure 5. Line Routes to Europe from Grand Inga 
                            (use Abu-Alam map from IEEE Review of July 1993) Figure 6. Multi-terminal interconnection between 
                            Russia and North America Table 3. Proposed Iceland/ UK Cable Connection 
                           Table 4. Tidal Power Sites Considered for Development 
                            Worldwide. Figure 7. Renewables Intensive Global Energy Scenario 
 References[1] Paris, L. and Zini. G. "Present 
                            Limits of Very Long Distance Transmission Systems." 
                            CIGRE Committee 37 Report, Paris, France, 1984. [2] World Population Prospects, United 
                            Nations, Department of International, Economic and 
                            Social Affairs, 1988. [3] Alam, M.S., Bala, B.K., Huo, 
                            A.M.Z. and Matin, M.A." A Model for the Quality 
                            of Life as a Function of Electrical Energy Consumption." 
                            Bangladesh Institute of Technology and University 
                            of Engineering and Technology, 1991, Vol. 16, (4). 
                           [4] Ager-Hanssen, H.J. "Energy 
                            for Tomorrow's World - The Realities, the Real Options 
                            and the Agenda for Achievement." Keynote Address, 
                            15th World Energy Council Congress, Madrid, Spain, 
                            20-25 September 1992, pp.1-7.  [5] Houghton, J., Jenkins, G. and 
                            Ephraums, J. "Climate Change: The IPCC Scientific 
                            Assessment." Cambridge University Press, UK, 
                            1990. [6] "Environmental Problems 
                            of Energy Production and Utilization." United 
                            Nations Committee on Natural Resources report to the 
                            Economic and Social Council, January 1971.  [7] Hammons, T.J., Falcon, J.A., 
                            Bateman, L.A., Lemay, J., Kern, E.C., Paris, L., Wolfe, 
                            M. H., Al-Shehri, A.M., El-Amin, I. M., Opoku, G. 
                            and Meisen, P. "Remote Renewable Energy Resources: 
                            Long-Distance High Voltage Interconnections. "IEEE 
                            Power Engineering Review, Vol. 12, (6), 1992, pp.3-25. 
                           [8] Hammons, T.J,. Vedavalli, R., 
                            Abu-Alam, Y., de Franco, N., Drolet, T. and McConnach, 
                            J .,"International Electric Network History and 
                            Future Perspectives on the United Nations and World 
                            Bank." IEEE Power Engineering Review, Vol. 13, 
                            (6), 1993, pp 12-24.  [9] Hammons, T.J., Olsen, A., Kacejko, 
                            P. and Leung, C.L., "Proposed Iceland/United 
                            Kingdom Power Link - An Indepth Analysis of Issues 
                            and Returns." IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, 
                            Vol. 8, ( ), 1993, pp - . [10] "The Potential of an Electrical 
                            Interconnection between Russia and North America." 
                            International Workshop, Anchorage, Alaska, USA, January 
                            1992.  [11] Hammons, T.J . "Advanced 
                            Power Generation Technologies - Tidal Power." 
                            Proceedings IEEE, 1993, Vol. 80, (3), 1993, pp.  [12] Hammons, T.J., Aisiks, E.G., 
                            Baker, G.C., Craig, J.W., Frau, J.P. and Thompson, 
                            I.,"Tidal Power." IEEE Power Engineering 
                            Review, Vol. 13, (3), 1993, pp - .   [13] Al-Alani, J ., Sud, S. and 
                            McGilles, D. "Planning of the Gulf States Interconnection". 
                            Report prepared for the Gulf States Cooperative Council, 
                            1991. [14] WEC Regional Reports CRS1 and 
                            CSR2 (South Asia and Pacific including China), 15th 
                            World Energy Council Congress, Madrid, Spain, 20-25 
                            September 1992. [15] Hammons, T.J., Covino, M., 
                            de Vasconcelos, A.V., Guieze, J.L., van Reeuwijk, 
                            P., Esser, C., Grossman, R.G., and Burton, N., "EC 
                            Community Policy on Electricity Infrastructure, Interconnections, 
                            and Electricity Exchanges." IEEE Power Engineering 
                            Review, Vol. 13, (5), 1993, pp  [16] Persoz, H., and Remondeuloz, 
                            J. "Cooperation in the Field of Electric Systems 
                            between Eastern and Western Europe," Proceedings 
                            of the World Energy Council Congress, Madrid, Spain, 
                            20-25 September 1992, paper 4.2-09, pp. 149-165. [17] Bohlin, S., Eriksson, K., Flisberg, 
                            G., ABB Power Systems, Ludvika, Sweden, "Electrical 
                            Transmission", World Energy Coalition Conference, 
                            1991. [18] Brower, M.C., Tennis, M.W., 
                            Denzler, E.W., Kaplan, M.M., "Powering the Midwest: 
                            Renewable Electricity for the Economy and the Environment", 
                            Union of Concerned Scientists Report, 1993. [19] Charles, B., "Australian 
                            Tidal Power", Engineering Times, Institute of 
                            Engineers Australia, June 1993. [20] Kuwano, Y., "GENESIS Project", 
                            Sanyo Electric Company, International Solar Energy 
                            Society, 1991 [21] Johanssen, T., Kelly, H., Reddy, 
                            A., Williams, R., "Renewable Energy - Sources 
                            for Fuels and Electricity", Island Press, 1993, 
                            pp 1 - 7. [22] Rudenko, Y. and Yershevich, 
                            V. "Is it Possible and Expedient to Create a 
                            Global Energy Network?" International Journal 
                            of Global Energy Issues, Vol. 3, (3), 1991.  
  
                              
   |