Lack of new power lines threatens renewable growth
While companies scramble to drive down the price of power
produced by sun and wind, many say a dearth of transmission
lines in remote areas ideal for wind farms and solar plants
is a bigger impediment than cost to spurring U.S. growth of
Demand is soaring for renewable energy projects to help reduce
both pollutants and consumption of ever-costlier fossil fuels.
At issue for developers of wind and solar projects, however,
is that the resources to power them are most abundant in sparsely
populated areas such as the Southwest's sun-baked Mojave desert
and the blustery plains of the Midwest.
Building lines to channel that clean electricity to urban
areas will be no small task, and renewable energy executives
at a conference in New York this week warned that many planned
solar and wind projects may never see the light of day if
policymakers do not expand power grids to accommodate them.
"Unless we figure out a way to move capital into transmission,
moving power from the Dakotas to Chicago or from the Mojave
to Los Angeles is going to be a great dream," Dan Reicher,
the executive in charge of Google Inc's green energy push,
said at the Renewable Energy Finance Forum.
He added that the progress of new transmission "in many respects
will define whether 2 percent or 20 percent of U.S. electricity
Problems integrating renewable power with the grid are already
playing out in Texas, the state with by far the most wind
Major power lines are needed to transfer wind generation
from West Texas to Dallas, Houston and San Antonio, where
electric demand is highest, and congestion on the state's
grid has sent power prices soaring.
Texas power regulators are weighing the benefits and costs
of new transmission lines that will cost several-billion dollars
to build, but executives said grid operators would not be
the only ones to foot the bill for such projects.
NOT IN MY BACK YARD
The head of BP Plc's alternative energy business, Vivienne
Cox, said the British oil major would consider putting some
of its considerable resources into transmission to help speed
the growth of its renewable energy developments.
"So far we haven't made big investments in infrastructure
projects, but I wouldn't rule that out at all," Cox told reporters
at the conference.
A bigger issue than costs, said many conference attendees,
will be agreeing on where to put the bulky transmission lines
needed to move considerable amounts of power.
"I don't think the barrier to transmission will be capital
adequacy or availability. It will be resistance to adding
capacity by people who don't want it in their neighborhood,"
Raymond Wood, head of Credit Suisse's alternative energy investment
banking practice, said at the conference.
As an example, the president of the Solar Energy Industries
Association trade group, Rhone Resch, pointed to a battle
in California over Sempra Energy unit San Diego Gas & Electric's
proposal to build a 150-mile (240-km) high-voltage transmission
line from the desert to San Diego that would go through a
Environmentalists argue the power line would ruin the park,
while the utility claims it will not be able to meet California's
renewable energy requirements without it.
Meanwhile, plans for thousands of megawatts of wind power,
solar thermal and geothermal projects in remote areas of the
United States are marching forward, and executives said power
lines to link them to the grid should already be in the works.
"A new transmission line cutting through a new route can
take five to 10 years to bring online," said Robert Rogan,
executive vice president of corporate development for eSolar,
a privately held solar thermal company backed by Google. "A
best case scenario requires that people are working on this
now." (Editing by Braden Reddall)